Nigeria: FIRS Seeks To Close Prolonged Tax Audits Using NORAs

Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) has recently been issuing Notice of Refusal to Amend (NORA) assessments issued in respect of on-going tax audit exercises. This is notwithstanding that taxpayers have objected such assessment notices or that some of the issues raised by FIRS have been resolved/documented at reconciliation meetings. In letters issued to some taxpayers, FIRS demanded settlement of the alleged additional tax liabilities within 30 days of issuance of the NORA, irrespective of the level of progress made during the tax audit reconciliation process. FIRS also expressed its intention to commence enforcement actions to recover the alleged tax liabilities where these are not paid within the said timeline. While Section 69(5) of the Companies Income Tax Act (CITA) empowers FIRS to issue NORA, it only allows FIRS to do so in the event of a stalemate during the reconciliation process. This is distinguishable from FIRS’ recent practice of issuing NORA solely on the basis that tax issues have remained unresolved for at least 6 months despite reconciliation. Furthermore, there is no provision in CITA or any other relevant legislation that empowers FIRS to issue NORA only on the basis that reconciliatory processes have spanned more than a defined period. By this development, FIRS has disregarded all the time and resources invested by itself and taxpayers in resolving such pending tax disputes. Aggrieved taxpayers may consider proceeding to the Tax Appeal Tribunal (TAT) to challenge FIRS’ action/decision; thereby increasing the cost of dispute resolution, regulatory compliance and ultimately, inhibiting the ease of doing business in Nigeria. In enforcing tax compliance, it is essential that tax authorities’ actions should not deter voluntary tax compliance. We therefore expect FIRS to revisit its approach and avail taxpayers more time to close out ongoing tax disputes/audit exercises. Also, where FIRS insists on issuing NORA, it should consider issues that have already been resolved during the reconciliation phase and focus only on unresolved tax issues. In the meantime, we advise taxpayers with ongoing tax audit cases to engage FIRS to reconcile their tax positions in order to prevent any adverse decision of FIRS.   Source: Mondaq

Nigeria: FIRS Seeks To Close Prolonged Tax Audits Using NORAs Read More »

ICAN seeks collaboration with finance ministry on training

The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN) on Tuesday commended the laudable achievements of the Federal Government under the Federal Ministry of Finance in the last three and half years, saying it has blocked leakages and set the tone for improved revenue generation to finance government’s economic development agenda. ICAN President, Alhaji Razak Adeleke Jaiyeola, who stated this when executive members of the organisation visited the Minister of Finance, Mrs Zainab Ahmed in Abuja, solicited the Ministry’s collaboration in organizing in-house training for staff and ICAN members in the Ministry. According to a statement by her Special Adviser on Media and Communications, Paul Abechi, the minister assured ICAN of the readiness of the ministry to collaborate with it. Ahmed who welcomed ICAN’s recently released Accountability Index, noted that the country was often measured by external index which did not take local peculiarities into consideration and that it will encourage both the federal and state governments to ensure good public governance. Speaking earlier, the ICAN President particularly noted the giant strides of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) under the President Muhammadu Buhari-led administration, which he said, has led to an all time high revenue generation of the sum of N5.3 trillion in 2018. While expressing worries over delays in national budget, Alhaji Jaiyeola, commended the implementation of the TSA, pointing out that many of the software that drive the process are not locally sourced. He called on the federal government to deploy more local content which he said will both preserve “our hard-earned foreign exchange and create more jobs for the citizenry”. According to him, “Let me seize this auspicious opportunity to warmly commend the laudable achievements recorded by the Federal Ministry of Finance in the last three and half years. The Treasury Single Account (TSA), the Voluntary Assets and Income Declaration Scheme (VAIDS), Whistle-blower Policy, the establishment of the Development Bank of Nigeria (DBN) and the Efficiency Unit, the Collateral Registry under the Central Bank of Nigeria, the laudable reforms in the FIRS, are all initiatives driven by your ministry not only to set a credible governance tone at the top and raise the bar of credibility.” He said the move of FIRS to recover N23 billion from 45,000 people who had more than N100 million in their accounts in 2018 through substitution of their bank account is highly commendable. On collaboration, the ICAN President said, “we are willing to collaborate with the Ministry of Finance at organizing in-house training for its staff and mandatory Professional Continuing Education (MCPE) for members of ICAN who work in the Ministry.” “As you are aware, ICAN released the first result of its Accountability Index during the 48th Annual Accountants’ Conference. This strategic initiative was jointly financed by ICAN and the Internal Federation of Accountants (IFAC). The ICAN-AI is an initiative for improving public sector finance management at the three tiers of government, he said. “The objectives of the ICAN AI among others include encouraging fiscal responsibility and good public financial management, tackling corruption by encouraging quality professionals in the public sector and providing a holistic, objective and evidenced-based framework for assessing performance of public sector entities, the ICAN boss added”.   Source: Today.ng

ICAN seeks collaboration with finance ministry on training Read More »

Wider tax net, not rate increase’ll raise government revenue –Olawale, NECA DG

The Federal Government’s intention to generate almost double of the amount realised last year in tax revenue may set it on collision path with the Organised Private Sector (OPS). The concern for a possible friction stems from the nation’s current economic situation, poor infrastructure, and difficulties in accessing funds among others, which members of the OPS are sounding a serious warning that the Federal Government would be making a mistake if it intends to generate the target revenue through tax increases. The new Director General of the Nigeria Employers Consultative Association (NECA), Mr. Timothy Olawale, lamented that businesses in Nigeria are presently encumbered with the payment of over 55 different taxes at the three levels of government. He also speaks on how banks have failed playing their role of ensuring small businesses thrive. Olawale, while expressing the readiness of the OPS to pay the new Minimum Wage of N30,000, said that anything below that is criminal. The NECA DG, among other issues, expressed worry over the nation’s rising debt profile, the Economic Recovery Growth Plan (ERGP) among other issues in the economy. Excerpts:  Support for new minimum wage We stuck out our neck on the issue of new minimum wage because it came out as a result of a process in which we are actively involved. We were actively part of the discussion, decision and we agreed and believed in the discussion of the tripartite committee with every sense of responsibility coupled with the fact that we believe in corporate responsibility. The second reason is that when you think about the welfare of workers, we believe N30,000 is ideal and that anything below that is inappropriate. Employers have the responsibility of taking care of their employees before they can increase productivity. You are not making life meaningful for them if you don’t pay them good salary. Is N30,000 really enough for workers? We all know the value and worth of money in the present economy. The question we should ask ourselves is how far will the N30,000 go in taking care of a worker and his or her entire family. By the time a worker goes to and from his/her workplace everyday, that N30,000 will substantially have gone. Don’t forget that there are also other basic needs like shelter, feeding, medicals, education for the children. So when you benchmark all these with the said amount, it can’t go far. And I want to say personally that anything below that is criminal. Effect of N30,000 minimum wage on the economy Yes, there is going to be a consequential effect, but it is going to be minimal and it is going to be controlled. One of the effects is that there is insufficient enlightenment to the general public to let them know that the fact that there is new minimum wage now, does not mean that everywhere will be awash with money.  Because based on that belief, there will be an increase in the prices of goods and services. Everyone, both market women and men, will want to benefit directly from the new minimum wage. And when that happens, the effect is that workers’ welfare will be totally lost. What it means is that the new minimum wage will not have any positive effect on the workers. The disadvantage of this is the prolonged process in arriving at the new minimum wage. Because everybody that doesn’t even know what minimum wage is all about before are aware now and are anticipating when it will take effect so that they will also benefit. It is so unfortunate, but that is Nigerians for you. OPS complying with new minimum wage There is no reason all members of the OPS should not be able to pay N30,000 minimum wage. This is because they all agreed after due consultation. So, we are saying authoritatively that all members of the OPS will implement N30,000. The simple truth is that 70 per cent of the organised labour is paying way above N30,000 as minimum wage. So, the consequential impact is very minimal, if not nil, because it is supposed to affect the chain or review, where your benchmark is below N30,000. So, if you are paying way above N30,000, you need not bother, except if you want to enter what we call a ‘sweetheart agreement’ with your workers and you decide to raise their salaries. As we speak, some sectors have started negotiating without waiting for government’s decision on the N30,000 proposal. My concern, however, is the informal sector – the Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs), which are struggling and don’t have enough support from the government and its agencies to survive. The question is: are they well positioned to absorb the effect of N30,000? Can they implement it? We have encouraged them to embrace the plan of relevant bodies like the International Labour Organisation (ILO), which NECA is a part of, to help them transit from informal to formal sector. This will help their businesses and deepen their access to capital. Also, they need to engage their workers because the major problem that has reflected in the rate of unemployment is that what Nigerians are even looking for is to be able to leave their houses and have a means of survival in the first instance. Majority of our teeming population are out of jobs; well over 30 million Nigerians are said to be out of job. Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs talks about subsistence level. In other words, the physiological need is: ‘Let me even have somewhere to go and have something to sustain myself and my family.’ It is after meeting that need that you start thinking of how to improve on it and then maybe the issue of minimum wage will arise. Our focus – and what we have always told the government – is for us to have a situation where majority are gainfully employed in the first instance. Then, we can talk about improving on it. We have also advised the

Wider tax net, not rate increase’ll raise government revenue –Olawale, NECA DG Read More »

N12.6tn generated as tax under Buhari, FIRS says

The Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) has disclosed that a total of N12.62 trillion was generated as revenue from  2016 to 2018. This was revealed in a document made available to newsmen by the Head of Communications and Servicom Department of the agency, Wahab Gbadamosi. N3.3 trillion was generated in 2016, N4.02 trillion in 2017 and N5.32 trillion was realised in 2018, making it the highest revenue generated in the last three years. The document stated that this was made possible as a result of several initiatives designed by the agency to ensure a robust tax administration that is beneficial to all stakeholders. It explained that non-oil tax revenue increased to N2.149 trillion in 2016, N2.5 trillion in 2017 and N2.852 trillion in 2018. The document quoted the Executive Chairman of the agency, Babatunde Fowler saying the achievement was a reflection of the diversification of the Nigerian economy by the Federal Government.  “This does not mean that we have left behind the oil tax revenues. It grew from N1.15 trillion in 2016 to N1.52 trillion in 2017 and N2.52trillion in 2018. Non-oil tax revenue is still over in excess of the oil tax revenue. “We also do collect four per cent in terms of cost of collection but only for non-oil revenue collected. On oil revenue collection, we do not get any commission and we have been able to make sure that our services are more efficient and convenient to taxpayers. “This has brought about a considerable reduction in the cost of collection of actual taxes. “In 2016, it was 2.6 per cent, 2017, 2.49 per cent and 2018, 2.14 per cent, meaning that our actual cost of collection is heading downwards based on the efficiency and technology that we are deploying to tax collection. “Some of the ICT initiatives that we have continued to build on are the e-payment channels which make it convenient and easy to pay taxes anywhere in the world and to also download receipts of payment from any point one so desires,” he said.   Source: RipplesNigeria

N12.6tn generated as tax under Buhari, FIRS says Read More »

Nigeria: Has The New Lease Rule Come To Change The Tax Space?

On 13 January, 2016, the International Accounting Standard Board (IASB) announced the issuance of a new accounting standard: International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 16, on leases, which took effect on 1 January 2019. The new standard has changed the basis of accounting for leases which was in force for more than thirty years. While IFRS 16 completely replaces the old rule under International Accounting Standard (IAS) 17, the major impact is on the recognition, measurement and disclosure requirements for lessees. The new standard eliminates the classification of leases as either operating or finance for lessees and, instead, introduces a single lessee accounting model. According to an IASB survey conducted in 2016, listed companies around the world had around US$3.3 trillion worth of leases. Based on IAS 17 requirements, over 85% of the leases are labelled as operating leases and are not recorded on the balance sheet of these companies. This amounts to about $2.8 trillion worth of leases off the balance sheet of such entities. Given the effective date of 1 January 2019 for the adoption of the new standard, most companies had about three years to evaluate the legal, commercial and financial reporting impact of the new standard on their financial positions and transactions. In this article, we have discussed the extent to which the new rule disrupts the Nigerian tax space, and the options available to companies and businesses moving forward. The Old Wine Explained In line with the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) information Circular No.2010/01 on Guidelines on the tax implication of Leases , a lease can be broadly defined as a contractual agreement between an owner (the lessor) and another party (the lessee) which conveys to the lessee the right to use the leased-asset for consideration usually periodic payments called rents. With the adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) in 2012, recognition of leases have been based on IAS 17 (the old rule). Under the old rule, a lease arrangement is classified as either an operating lease or a finance lease. Finance leases are arrangements that transfer risk and rewards relating to the use of an asset from the lessor to the lessee. This means that in a finance lease arrangement, the lessee is deemed the economic owner of the asset since he is able to apply the asset to generate economic benefits from continuous usage. All other types of lease arrangements are classified as operating lease. Accounting by Lessee and Lessor under the Old Rule – Finance Lease Under the old rule, lessees were required to recognize a finance lease arrangement as both an asset and a liability at an amount equal to the fair value (sale price agreed upon by a willing buyer and seller, assuming both parties enter the transaction freely and knowledgeably) of leased asset. Where this value is lower than the fair value, recognition should be based on the present value of the minimum lease payments to be made by the lessee. Finance (interest) charge is also accrued on the liability over the term of the lease. Subsequently, the annual lease payment made by the lessee is applied towards settling the liability and finance charge that has accrued in relation to the arrangement. Thus, by the end of the lease term, the lessee would have paid for the fair value of the asset plus the finance charge on the leased assets. The lessee depreciates (it may fair value or revalue alternatively) the leased assets annually and charges the annual finance (interest) cost to its income statement. Since risk and rewards are transferred in a finance lease, lessors are not allowed to recognize the leased asset in their books. Rather, they recognize a receivable (from the lessee) equal to the fair value of the leased asset. Additionally, lessors recognize annual finance income receivable from lessee over the term of the lease. Accounting by Lessee and Lessor under the Old Rule – Operating Lease Under operating lease, lessors retain the risk and rewards. Hence, lessees are not allowed to recognize any asset. Lessees recognize operating lease payment as periodic expense on a straight-line basis over the term of the lease. Lessors however continue to carry the asset in its books, depreciating them on annual basis. Additionally, they recognize the operating lease rental receivable from lessee over the term of the lease from lessees as periodic income in the income statements. Tax Implications of the Old Rule The Companies Income Tax Act provides for the tax treatments of leases. The tax treatments are also explained in the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) Circular on the Tax Implication of the Adoption of the IFRS. It should be noted that the prescribed tax treatment aligns with the old rule under IAS 17. Under a finance lease arrangement, lessees have the responsibility to deduct withholding tax on the annual finance/interest charge while they claim capital allowance on the leased asset. The interest charge constitutes a deductible expense when computing their income tax liability. For lessors, the finance income constitutes a taxable income and they are not allowed to claim capital allowance on the leased assets. For operating lease arrangement, the lessee deducts withholding tax on the annual operating lease rental while the lessor accounts for the VAT on the amount. The lease rental constitute deductible expense and taxable income in the books of the lessee and lessor respectively. Additionally, the lessor continues to claim capital allowance on the asset. What has Changed? The new rule retains the two categories of leases, operating and finance, for the lessor, as well as the recognition under the old rule. However, it prescribes a single accounting treatment for lessees. The new rule requires lessees to recognize a “right-of-use asset” and a lease liability at the inception of the lease. The lease liability is measured at the present value of outstanding lease payment. The recognized liability accrues finance (interest) charges over the term of the lease and any payment made by the lessee is used to settle the original

Nigeria: Has The New Lease Rule Come To Change The Tax Space? Read More »

Tax: These three companies are on course to deliver lower profits for FY2018, here’s why

The year 2018 was not the best of years for the stock market but the economy grew at its fastest pace since the recession in 2016 after real gross domestic product in 2018 expanded at 1.9 percent. Companies like Zenith Bank and Dangote who have released their 2018 results have seen strong profit growth in the past year, however, BusinessDay has identified 3 companies who despite having a better business performance in 2018 than in 2017 are on course to still deliver lower profits when their full year results are released, and you will never guess why. In 2017, companies like Seplat, Forte Oil and Presco had Uncle Sam to thank for their big profit after tax (PAT) figures. These three companies received combined tax credits from the government totaling around N83.7 billion, which helped boost their bottom-line figures significantly. The highest tax credit was enjoyed by Seplat who received about N67.6 billion, which helped the company report full year PAT of N81.1 billion in 2017 after the oil exploration company had earned only N13.4 billion in profit before tax (PBT). Based on projections using the 2018 Q3 report, analysts now expect that excluding any tax credit, the full year profit of the oil company will be around N36 billion, representing a profit decline of around 56 percent. Don’t be fooled by the bottom-line numbers though, Seplat had one of its best years in 2018. Although net profit could decline, the company will deliver revenue growth of around 67 percent while PBT will jump around 444 percent, capping a fantastic year for the company after the oil price rebound has helped boost revenue and allowed the company pay down some of its debt. Analysts told BusinessDay that they do not expect Seplat to allow its PAT to fall that low considering they could still call on more tax credits in 2018. The company currently holds around N41.83 billion in deferred tax asset and has already paid about N9.6 billion of tax liabilities in advance as at the end of Q3 2018. Therefore, the oil producer still has more tax credits to collect at their disgression which may see them report profits that significantly exceeds our forecasted N36 billion PAT. A deferred tax asset is an asset on a company’s balance sheet that may be used to reduce taxable income. It is created when recorded income taxes payable are higher than the income taxes paid to the government. Presco, one of Nigeria’s largest oil palm producing companies is expected to see its PAT decline to N7 billion in 2018 from N25.4 billion in 2017. Presco owes most of its profit in 2017 to the government after it received about N14.4 billion in tax credit, adding to its PBT of around N10.9 billion. The tax credit accounted for around 57 percent of PAT and 132 percent of PBT. Asides the tax credit, Presco’s profit was also lifted by revaluation gains of around N2.78 billion which analysts now expect that the revaluation gains and tax credits may not be available for pickup as it was last year. Another oil company with a similar story is Forte Oil which has been in the news lately as its former owner is currently divesting away from the company. In 2017, Forte Oil received tax credit of around N1.6 billion, which helped the company deliver PAT of around N12.2 billion after the company reported N10.6 billion in PBT. This year, analysts project that the company’s full year 2018 PAT will be around N8.9 billion if Uncle Sam fails to extend a helping hand once again. Unlike Seplat, the company’s revenue and PBT is expected to be slightly lower in 2018 than it was in 2017 due to sluggish sales. “We will have to wait and see if these companies take a hit on profit in 2018 when their full year reports are released. While I see Forte oil and Presco reporting lower yearend profit, its possible Seplat will deliver profits that show marginal growth if the deferred tax assets are converted to tax credits in their reports,” said Tochukwu Okafor, Lecturer in Banking and Finance department at Covenant University. Dangote Cement another benefactor of tax credits in 2018 reported its highest profit ever in 2018 after it collected tax credit of around N89.5 billion when it secured its pioneer status last year. Analysts say the company may struggle to match its N390.3 billion PAT it achieved last year in 2019.   Source: Business day

Tax: These three companies are on course to deliver lower profits for FY2018, here’s why Read More »

Court reportedly asks Monalisa Chinda to be arrested for tax evasion

A High Court in Lagos, has reportedly ordered that actress Monalisa Chinda, should be arrested for failing to pay income tax over a 6-year period. In a report by The Nation News on Sunday, March 3, 2019, it was alleged that the actress had failed to obey a request asking her to show up in court. As a result, Justice Adedayo Akintoye, insisted that she must be apprehended in an order reportedly given on Monday, January 21, 2019. “The defendant has been served with hearing notice. The proof of service is in the court’s file,” a statement from prosecutor Y.A Pitan reads. The counsel mentioned this while asking for a bench warrant to arrest the actress who has reportedly been evasive. Monalisa Chinda is alleged to be found wanting for refusing to fulfill an obligation to pay tax to the Lagos State government for her business located in Lekki on the Lagos Island. The accusation has resulted in a 2-count charge, one of which alleged “failure to furnish and file annual tax returns for the purpose of personal income taxation with the Lagos State Internal Revenue Service (LIRS) contrary to Section 94(1) of the Personal Income Tax Act 2004 (as amended).” According to The Nation, the bench warrant to arrest the actress shall extend up until April, having failed to appear in court two months earlier.   Source: Pulse

Court reportedly asks Monalisa Chinda to be arrested for tax evasion Read More »

FIRS and 85,000 millionaire tax defaulters

A disclosure the other day by the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) boss about possible pursuit of 85,000 millionaire tax defaulters is curious and unfortunate. There is no reason for serious alarm before such a critical service can be delivered and the reasons are not too far to seek. Tax payment to governments by qualified individuals and corporate organisations, has been a feature of both the ancient and modern world. It is generally recognised as a civic duty or responsibility through which governments gather revenue/financial resources with which the machinery of state and the common needs of the people are satisfied. Essentially, payment of tax is important for governments and their institutions to survive and serve the needs of the people. Every qualified taxpayer ought to know and comply with this basic need of paying due tax. And so, the other day, a report that the Federal Inland Revenue Services (FIRS) was seeking help from and collaboration with other stakeholders like the Nigeria Police Force (NPF), to catch-up with “wealthy tax defaulters” to cause them to fulfil their tax obligations, sounded unthinkable that the wealthy in our midst could be fingered as part of tax defaulters in the country. Despite having been rewarded with wealth through their various undertakings and endeavours, the little they are ordinarily expected to do is to support the machinery of the government and the welfare of the people. No one expected them to fail to pay their taxes. To have chosen to default in their tax obligations is to say the least the highest level of ingratitude and no doubt, irresponsibility. According to the report, out of the N5.32 trillion tax revenue FIRS achieved in 2018, about N2.3 billion was recovered from 45,000 “wealthy tax defaulters.” Against this development, FIRS plans to go “after another set of over 40,000 millionaire tax defaulters in 2019.”  It is necessary to observe that FIRS claimed to have been scrutinising accounts of banks’ customers for the purpose of its tax revenue generation. Indeed, there have been reports that the apex tax agency has engaged in placing liens on bank accounts of suspected tax defaulters. Placement of such liens means that the affected bank customers will be unable to have access, in part or whole, to their account balances until they resolve whatever the issues may be with FIRS. In other words, affected bank customers will not be able to make withdrawals until they settle tax liabilities dictated by FIRS. It is, therefore, obvious that FIRS, in its tax revenue drive, is using coercive method to compel individuals and organisations to pay tax. This is curious in the polity. While tax revenue, like other revenue sources open to governments, is essential for the government to be able to carry out its duties and responsibilities in the interest of the citizenry, there is hardly any doubt that FIRS must ensure that whatever method it has adopted or plans to adopt in pursuit of suspected tax evaders is in line with subsisting legal and regulatory provisions. This is even more exigent if the tax agency has to pass through the banks in its recovery of tax debts.  It should be noted that banks, as custodians of public and private funds, have obligations to their customers, especially with regard to confidentiality of transactions. So, any attempt or indeed breach of this near-sacred and long-established understanding between banks and their customers, (outside what is permitted by law) has implications not just for the banks but also the larger economy. As is well known, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) always laments that the amount of money outside the banking system is very high. In spite of CBN’s efforts to bring much of the money outside into the banking system, successes recorded are yet to change the situation significantly. Consequently, effectiveness of monetary policies has remained impaired. And this is not in the best interest of the economy. On the other hand, banking institutions are having their own challenges – rising bad debts, poor liquidity, fraud, money laundering, etc). It is foreseeable that FIRS’ debt recovery approach will send signals -right or wrong- to customers of banks. One such signal may be that it is no longer safe for persons to keep their money in banks, without intrusion by third parties. When such happens, customers, who ordinarily have multiplicity of choices, will begin to consider alternatives to safekeeping and safe-guarding as well as utilisation of their funds. Consequently, more funds will find their way outside banks.  If this country returns to a situation where banks’ customers avoid or minimise using the banking system, the first casualties will be the banks. Their deposit portfolio will significantly decrease and with very high debt levels in banks already, an invitation to banks’ distress will, knowingly or otherwise, have been made. If the situation reaches a critical state where many banks may become distressed, Nigerians and their government will most certainly begin to place side by side tax debt recovery vis-a-vis banks’ distress to decide which, among the two, should be placed on hold. Therefore, for FIRS to continue or commence its intended incursion into the banking industry for the purposes of recovering tax revenues outstanding against the wealthy, it is imperative that both the regulators of the banking system and operators, at the highest level of decision-making, must properly and effectively engage themselves, prior to embarking on this explosive venture. There is the need to thoroughly consider and abide by legal and regulatory provisions. Proper planning and setting up of implementation procedures as well as consistent public awareness and/or orientation are important. In all respects, arbitrariness, high handedness and breach of relevant subsisting laws and regulations must be eschewed.  So, in the main, tax payment is a worldwide legitimate and civic responsibility of persons who are not exempted (for varying reasons) from such payments. Therefore, every tax liable person has a responsibility to meet such liability without waiting for the tax man’s knock on the door. Whether

FIRS and 85,000 millionaire tax defaulters Read More »

N170m FIRS Contract Fraud: Court stops Zinox Computers’ from gagging

A court in Abuja on Thursday blocked an attempt by Zinox Technologies Limited to suppress press freedom and stop PREMIUM TIMES from continuing its reporting on the allegation of N170 million contract fraud against the computer firm. In its ruling on the motion by Zinox Technologies seeking an injunction to restrain PREMIUM TIMES from further reporting the scandal, the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, Apo, Abuja, dismissed the application for lack of merit. In his judgment, Justice SC Oriji said a close examination of the totality of evidence and address by Zinox Technologies did not show any cogent reason why the court should grant the injunction in its favour. According to the judge, a media organisation cannot be restrained from publishing a report yet to be proven legally as libellous. The judge said when a media organisation considers its publication factual, and its publishers have sworn to defend the facts of the publication, the court will infringe on the public’s right to know if it stops the press from exercising the responsibility guaranteed under Section 39 of the Constitution. Consequently, the Court dismissed the application by Zinox Technologies and upheld PREMIUM TIMES’ argument that the former had no good reason to warrant the Court granting the injunction. The matter was adjourned to March 11 for the hearing of their motion for extension of time within which they can file their reply to our statement of defence. ROOTS OF THE CASE On May 15, 2017, Zinox Technologies, an affiliate of Zinox Group, filed a suit seeking to restrain PREMIUM TIMES and some of its officials from continuing its reporting on the N170.3 million contract fraud scandal involving five of the company’s officials, including its top management. Zinox had accused the newspaper’s editors of libelling it and its chairman, Stanley Ekeh, through the series of publications on the scam. Apart from its demand for N2 billion in damages, Zinox asked for an order of perpetual injunction restraining PREMIUM TIMES from further publication, an apology as well as court directive for the removal from the newspaper’s website series of publications on the scandal. But, PREMIUM TIMES pushed back with a counter application demanding N10 billion as damages against Zinox Technologies and its top officials, for attempting to suppress press freedom by asking the court to stop the discharge of its role inform the public factually on issues in the society. Pending the commencement of hearing on the substantive suit, Zinox, on December 3, 2018, filed an application seeking the court’s injunction to restrain PREMIUM TIMES from publishing any further report on fraud scandal against its top officials. Hearing on the matter was adjourned to January 8. At the resumed sitting, after arguments were heard from both parties, the court adjourned till February 28 for the ruling, and commencement of hearing on the substantive suit. On Thursday, the court ruled against Zinox in favour of PREMIUM TIMES. But, the commencement of hearing on the main suit, which was earlier scheduled to commence immediately, was adjourned to March 18, 2018. Counsel to PREMIUM TIMES, Jude Muoka, hailed the judge for delivering a sound and erudite judgment by upholding the right of the press to publish factual and credible information and defending the right of the public to know. “We have always known the application was never on a firm foundation. Zinox Technologies and its officials were only using the application to attempt to shield themselves from the searchlight of the public over the scandal,” Mr Muoka said. Meanwhile, during the court sitting, Mr Muoka said he drew the court’s attention to the continued publication of defamatory materials against PREMIUM TIMES. Some of the publications surfaced in various online platforms a fortnight ago about the purported clearance by the police and the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to the accused Zinox top officials over the fraud scandal. The reports featured in publications including Sabi News, Brand Spur, Grassroots.NG,   Communications Week, Independent, ThisisLagos, and Latest Nigerian News. But, the police and EFCC have since denied knowledge about the substance of the reports. EFCC spokesperson, Tony Orilade, told PREMIUM TIMES the question of clearance to Zinox does not even arise because it is not part of the mandate of the anti-graft agency. “As a rule, EFCC does not give clearance to any person or group in cases under prosecution. It is only the courts that are authorised to do so after the matter has been diligently prosecuted and the accused person or group discharged and acquitted,” he said. Also, police spokesperson, Frank Mba, said he had no knowledge about Police clearance of the Zinox officials. “I am not aware of any such report (of clearance of Zinox officials), I can assure you. I don’t know anything about it, and I don’t have anything to do about it for now,” Mr Mba said on the telephone.   Source: Dabawa

N170m FIRS Contract Fraud: Court stops Zinox Computers’ from gagging Read More »

No Person/Firm Can Collect Tax/Levy On Behalf Of Any Government In Any Part Nigeria

NO PERSON/FIRM CAN COLLECT TAX/LEVY ON BEHALF OF ANY GOVERNMENT IN ANY PART NIGERIA. Taxes/Levies are serious issues in any part of the world. They are created by government and their prices/amounts are certain and predictable. In Nigeria, all taxes/levies must be created by law and be assessed and collected by either Federal, State or Local Governments. None of the governments can engage, authorise, delegate, use or appoint any person, firm or group to assess or collect taxes/levies on its behalf. The only appropriate tax authorities empowered and allowed to assess and collect taxes/levies in Nigeria are the Federal Inland Revenue Services(FIRS), the State Board of Internal Revenue and Local Government Revenue Committee, by whatever name they call themselves in the respective states and local governments across Nigeria. As well as an Ministry, Government department or any other Government body charged with responsibility for assessing or collecting a particular tax. NOTE, that no State Government (including its House of Assembly) or Local Government has powers to make any law or Bye-Law that will allow the appointment and engagement of any person/firm in the assessment or collection of any tax/levy in any part of Nigeria. I have seen several persons and firms parading letters of engagement from some tax/levy agencies of government, such person should be properly guided. If you have tax/levy issues/challenges, kindly talk to your lawyer or tax consultant. It is your right to know. My authorities are sections 2 and 5 as well as the Schedule to the Taxes and Levies (Approved List for Collection) Act, 1998 and the Schedule to the Taxes and Levies (Approved List for Collection) Act, (Amendment) Order 2015. Also Sections 4(5), 7(5), Paragraphs 7, 8 and 9, Part II of Second Schedule and Paragraph 1(J) of the Fourth Schedule to the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999.   Source: Thenigerialawyer

No Person/Firm Can Collect Tax/Levy On Behalf Of Any Government In Any Part Nigeria Read More »

Loading...